Dieselpunks

Dieselpunk + Steampunk Culture

could Diesel/Steam stories in which the nazis didnt exist,or never came to power,be classed as Holocaust Denial?

Views: 595

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

What was it Dicken's said? "The law is an ass" However being a work of fiction should likely be enough of a defence against any stupid laws like that.

Denial of the Holocaust falls under the pretenses that you are presenting your work as historical fact.

Any dieselpunk story would automatically be classified as fiction by default, and Nazis weren't even around in Victorian times, so they wouldn't fit into the Steampunk paradigm.

hopefully you are right,but strange things are happening in europe at the moment.

What are you referring to?

I just happened to finish a book in which Nazi rule effectively ended in 1938. It never occured to me that I'm denying the Shoah (Hebrew name of the Holocaust). And I want to see someone who'll accuse me of it.

sorry :my reply was written before i saw Tome Wilson's answer.in europe at the moment there is a lot of talk about expanding the range of things covered by holocaust denial laws. also i have read steampunk literature which goes into the 1960's and mentions the nazis.

well put point Philip Vandenberg

Another more relevant problem might be that in certain countries the use of the Swastika is forbidden. So any kind of object which features it, could get you in trouble with the law in, for example, Germany. Keep this in mind if you decide to make a model zeppelin with nazi insignia or similar.

I bought a copy of an old advertising poster in Germany. The original featured a swastika on the airship, but on the reproduction that had been removed.

Unless you make a DP world where Hitler takes over Europe and everything is all lovely and nice and Jews live in a utopian German protectorate in Isreal then no, it's not "Holocaust denial lit" by any reasonable doubt. It's Alternate History. No one accused Harry Turtledove of being a denier in his victorious CSA timeline where the Central Powers win WW1 and Hitler is just a pissed off antisemetic corporal and millions of Jews live on in Europe. No one accused Michael Chabon of denial when he wrote The Yiddish Policeman's Union where (many of) Europe's Jews are relocated to Sitka Alaska. Of course both being Jewish American probably helped, but no, it's not "Denial" just to not have a holocaust in your world. In fact, depending on the setting and how you portray Jews in it, it may become a fabulous piece of anti-antisemetism highlighting the contributions Jewish culture and people have had on the world and the evil and idiocy of history's Nazis for their crimes against them.

all good points,and well argued.thank you.however a point has been raised which needs comment:the ban on swastikas.i am not going to go through the history of this ancient human symbol as its easy to find,but i will argue that the ban is wrong and demonizes a beautiful symbol(see the Hindu examples).the Hebrews also valued it enough to decorate their ancient synagogues with,so why not publicise it and reclaim it for humanity

Stefan helped us out with this issue last March.  Here are his thoughts on the swastika law in Europe.

It is also to be noted that European laws are not equally respected in all European countries, or so it seems. While Northern countries (UK, France, Netherlands, Germany of course...) are rather strict about it, Southern countries tend to have a more "anything goes" attitude : in every Madrid souvenirs shops, you are likely to find small size (or not so) statues of Franco, Hitler, etc... and in Italy, unlike in Germany, all buildings from the Mussolini era are still there, complete with the fascist emblems. As for Eastern countries, just a look at Deviant Art and the profile of the galleries owners tells a lot about the kids' fascination for the nazi mythos and the large use they make of its symbols and representation in these countries.

Via Wikipedia

"In many European countries, and more specifically in Germany, according to the Strafgesetzbuch section 86a, the Number 86a article of law, it is prohibited to make any use of the swatiska that is not an historical use, under penalty of jail. Thus, even anti-nazi drawings of trashed swatiskas are paradoxically illegal because of these laws.

Mr Bradley, I wasn't saying the law isn't an ass in this case as well. Just that in some countries, swastikas are banned. Claiming it's a replica of something historical, doesn't seem to be enough of a defence. In fact I think if we posted pictures of swastikas on this website, people from Germany might be getting in trouble for accessing it.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Stay in touch

FacebookTwitterRSS

Allied Powers

Diesel powered dieselpunk podcast
Dieselpunk Industries
Seance Media by Tome Wilson
Vnv Nation

© 2019   Created by Tome Wilson.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service